Riley v. Dempsey (2005)

Citation: Riley v. Dempsey (2005)
Parent Document: Riley v. Dempsey (2005)
Jurisdiction: Vermont (state)
Effective Date: 2005-01-05
Original Source: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/4490187/riley-v-dempsey/ ↗

Full Text

852 chars

On appeal before the Superior Court, the standard of review is limited. The appeal must
be heard and decided “based on the record made in the Small Claims Court.” 12 V.S.A. § 5538.
The appellate court will not set aside findings of fact unless they are clearly erroneous. Bartley-
Cruz v. McLeod, 144 Vt. 263, 264 (1984). The appellate court gives less deference to the trial
court with regard to issues of law. However, the weight of the evidence and the credibility of
witnesses are for the Small Claims Court as the trier of fact. Brown v. Pilini, 128 Vt. 324, 328
(1970). When reviewing questions of fact, this court does not substitute its judgment for that of
the Small Claims Court. Whipple v. Lambert, 145 Vt. 339, 341 (1985). Also see Vermont Rules
of Small Claims Procedure 10(d) (appeals limited to questions of law). Issues Raised on Appeal

Other Sections in This Document (45)

Full Text