Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)

Citation: Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Parent Document: Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Jurisdiction: Vermont (state)
Effective Date: 2005-01-14
Original Source: https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/8209845/fletcher-hill-inc-v-crosbie/ ↗

Other Sections in This Document (57)

Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)
Fletcher Hill, Inc. v. Crosbie, 178 Vt. 77 (2005)

Full Text

378 chars

Although the majority recognizes that the statute is mandatory, it upholds the trial court decision as within its “exercise of discretion.” The majority concludes that there was no substantially prevailing party in this case because the “jury verdict... resulted in awards to both parties” and because part of plaintiff’s recovery will go to pay off a subcontractor. Ante, ¶ 13.